Seeing Grey Market and Channel Diversion in Your Own Data

How the grey market and channel diversion arise, where they hurt a brand, when they can be stopped in law, and what data changes in that dispute.

On the grey market the product on the shelf is genuine. The problem is that it is being sold in a country the brand did not plan for, by a seller it did not authorise, or far below the intended price. Known as the grey market, parallel trade or channel diversion, this is governed by different legal rules from counterfeiting. The damage to pricing, the dealer network and the customer experience can be just as serious.

What separates the three terms?

  • Grey market: genuine products sold outside the brand owner's authorised distribution channel.
  • Parallel trade: genuine products bought in one market and moved to another to be sold there without the brand owner's consent.
  • Channel diversion: stock allocated to a specific country, corporate customer, tender buyer or discount programme being redirected to another channel.

In all three the product is genuine; what is in dispute is the path it took.

Why does a product leave its channel?

There is usually a price or cost gap behind it:

  1. Price differences: differences in list prices, taxes or exchange rates between countries or channels make buying in one place and selling in another profitable.
  2. Volume incentives: target-based discounts push dealers to take more stock than they need and pass the surplus to other channels.
  3. Specially priced channels: products set aside for corporate sales, tenders or export come back to the domestic market or go to a third one.
  4. Marketplaces: an unauthorised seller can easily reach a wide audience with products gathered from various sources.
  5. Returns and stock clearance: returned products, end-of-season stock or products due for destruction leak into uncontrolled channels.

Where does the damage show up?

The authorised dealer has to compete with the same product at a lower price from another source. Investing in stock and service makes less sense, and the complaint usually lands with the sales team first.

Product suitability is a second problem. A product made for another market may have labelling, a user-manual language, warranty terms or a formulation that does not fit the destination market. In an uncontrolled channel there is also no knowing how the product was stored; for temperature-sensitive products that is a direct quality risk.

Unauthorised channels also give cover to counterfeiting. Mixing fakes in among genuine products is easy there. The 2025 OECD and EUIPO report notes that counterfeiters exploit online platforms and modern logistics to infiltrate legitimate trade.

Finally, data is lost. When nobody knows where and to whom a product was sold, demand planning, recalls and warranty processes run on guesswork.

When can a grey product be stopped in law?

Not every grey product is a trade mark infringement. The deciding concept is exhaustion of rights.

Regional exhaustion in the EU

Under Article 15 of Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 on the European Union trade mark, a trade mark proprietor cannot rely on the trade mark to prohibit its use in relation to goods put on the market in the European Economic Area (EEA) by the proprietor or with their consent. Legitimate reasons, such as the condition of the goods being changed or impaired after they were put on the market, are the exception to that rule.

In its 1998 Silhouette judgment, the Court of Justice of the European Union held that member states cannot provide for exhaustion in respect of goods put on the market outside the EEA. That is why parallel trade within the EEA is in principle free, while bringing goods first marketed outside the EEA into the EEA without the proprietor's consent can be prevented through the trade mark.

Article 152 of the Industrial Property Law in Türkiye

Under Article 152 of Industrial Property Law No. 6769, once protected products have been put on the market by the right holder or by third parties with their consent, acts relating to those products fall outside the scope of the right. The proprietor retains the right to prevent commercial use of those products where third parties have changed or impaired them.

Unlike the EU provision, the article contains no geographic limit on where the products were put on the market. How that difference plays out in a specific parallel import case is a question for legal assessment, and a brand should get specialist advice on its own situation.

Contracts and competition law

Where trade mark rights do not reach, distribution agreements take over. In the EU, the Vertical Block Exemption Regulation 2022/720 keeps within the exemption restrictions on sales by members of a selective distribution system, and by their customers, to unauthorised distributors in the territory where the system operates. For the exemption to apply, neither the supplier's nor the buyer's share of the relevant market may exceed 30 per cent; the regulation runs until 31 May 2034. Drafting such restrictions so that they comply with competition law is a separate specialism.

All of these legal and contractual tools rest on the same thing: being able to prove where, and by whom, the product was put on the market. That proof comes from the shipment record.

What can the data prove?

Regulators have used this logic in medicines for a long time. In Türkiye, the Pharmaceutical Track and Trace System records the inbound and outbound movements of every medicine pack and follows its latest location and status. The EU's falsified medicines rules require wholesalers to verify the unique identifier of products returned to them and of products received from a wholesaler that is neither the manufacturer, the wholesaler holding the marketing authorisation nor one designated by the marketing authorisation holder in a written contract.

In sectors where no legislation requires it, the same principle rests on two records: which dealer or market the product was shipped to, and where it was later scanned. If the serial or batch number is matched to the dealer at despatch, the exit point of a product found in the market can be traced backwards. When individual units are linked to cases and pallets, as in GS1's EPCIS standard, that record can be kept at shipment level without scanning every unit. When a test purchase from an unauthorised seller is scanned, the dealer the product was shipped to becomes clear and the matter can be handled under the contract.

Scan data also separates counterfeiting from the grey market. The same code scanned many times in different places points to copying; a single scan in an unexpected market points to channel diversion. Because the legal route differs between the two, it matters that the distinction is backed by data. Tagvex's grey market article explains in detail how the shipment and scan records are read side by side.

Where to start

Data is only useful when it is collected consistently. Three things need to be in place:

  • The dealer agreement states how chain-of-custody records are kept and who is responsible for scanning.
  • Field staff and dealers who will scan products are brought into the process.
  • The data collected is designed in line with data protection legislation.

The first product group is the one with the largest price gap and the most frequent diversion; that is where results show up soonest.

Spectrace offers two products for this record. The Tagvex secure label records every change of hands from the line to the warehouse, the dealer and the customer with a unique number for each product, or each batch; scans in unexpected places and repeated scans are flagged in the record. Authex monitors unauthorised sellers on marketplaces and social media and documents the findings. These records do not replace legal assessment; they give it something to work with.

Sources

grey marketparallel tradechannel diversiontraceabilitydealer management

Request a meeting

The right solution for your product follows from a needs analysis.

In the first meeting we review your product, sales channels and the risks you face, then recommend a verification method that fits.

Request a meeting